Skip to content
FeaturedVerifiedHome Builders in Carmel, Indiana

Old Town Design Group

Featured in Carmel Today 4.80 (48 reviews)(317) 816-3151

Old Town Design Group is a Carmel-based home builder offering custom homes, curated homes and townhomes across central Indiana. Its integrated team includes site planners, architects, construction managers and interior designers.

Business Highlights
  • BuilderTrend keeps the construction timeline on track.
  • Old Town Design Group provides a complete home warranty.

Service Area

Carmel, Westfield, Fishers, Noblesville, Zionsville, West Lafayette, Franklin and Bargersville.

Featured on ProsGrade. Old Town Design Group is one of 9 home builders ProsGrade lists in Carmel, Indiana.

Listing details

4 services listed, including Custom home building, Curated homes and Townhome construction. Open weekdays, closed on weekends. Rated 4.8 from 48 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Old Town Design Group compares with the other 8 home builders on ProsGrade in Carmel, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Ranks in the top quarter of the 9 Carmel home builders on ProsGrade by Google rating and review volume.
  • Rated 4.8 on Google, well above the 4.4 average of other Carmel home builders on ProsGrade.
  • Has more Google reviews (48) than 7 of the 8 other Carmel home builders on ProsGrade.
  • One of 2 Carmel home builders on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

4 services
  • Custom home buildingIn-house initial design; firm, fixed pricing after final design.
  • Curated homesMore than 35 floor plans in Craftsman, Modern, American Standard and Farmhouse styles.
  • Townhome constructionFloor plans and interior design vignettes can be selected before the foundation is poured.
  • Building on clients’ lotsFree lot consultations.

Reviews

What customers say

Customers praise clear communication during the building process; one client specifically valued weekly updates. One neighbor complained of litter lasting more than two years and a blocked driveway.

Customer Reviews

Emily Eaton

Old town has a tough time respecting the private property of those surrounding their builds. It’s been 2+ years of litter, trespassing, and blocking our driveway. Their own employees don’t even follow their own signage. Can’t wait til they’re done with this project.
View full reviewShow less

Aaron Hohenbrink

I had the pleasure of working with Old Town Design Group through the planning process for a custom home in Westfield Indiana. Although I ultimately decided it wasn’t the right financial decision for me at this time, I couldn’t have been more impressed with the experience. Adam (sales) and Nate (architect) were both fantastic—knowledgeable, fair, and incredibly helpful every step of the way. The process was exceptionally well-organized, far better than my experiences with previous builders. Nate worked closely with me over several months to design a home I absolutely loved, capturing every detail I had hoped for. Even when challenges arose, Old Town made every effort to find creative solutions and make the build feasible. While it wasn’t in the cards for me right now, I wouldn’t hesitate to work with them in the future. If you’re looking for a builder who truly listens, collaborates, and delivers a seamless and professional design process, I highly recommend Old Town Design Group.
View full reviewShow less

Janet Clark

We found Old Town Design Group to be a pleasure to work with as we built our new home. The communication and workmanship was top notch. Any questions or concerns we had were addressed promptly and we feel they went out of their way to make this a great experience. We would highly recommend them to anyone interested in building a new home.
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Old Town Design Group’s lot evaluation cover?

Its lot analysis uses laser technology to assess grade, home placement and potential water issues.

What happens after a home is complete?

Old Town offers a new-home orientation. After closing, it schedules a 45-day walkthrough and an 11-month follow-up to allow time to submit a warranty claim.