American Heritage Homes
American Heritage Homes
American Heritage Homes builds custom homes on customers’ land throughout Central Ohio, including the Columbus metropolitan area. It began in 1995 with Bill Crum and Gary Libertini, who still lead the company.
Business Highlights
- It reports receiving an Avid CX Gold Award for customer experience in custom homebuilding.
- It says it has been a BIA of Central Ohio member since 1995.
Service Area
Central Ohio: all or portions of Delaware, Union, Madison, Licking, Fairfield, Pickaway, Ross, Perry, Hocking, Morrow, Muskingum, Clark, Champaign and Fayette counties.
Featured Local Business
American Heritage Homes is one of 4 home builders ProsGrade lists in Columbus, Ohio.
3 services listed: Custom home building, Designer Collection floor plans and Simplified Collection floor plans. Open Monday to Saturday. Rated 4.3 from 46 reviews.
- Verified listing details
- Service information
- Customer review signals
- Photo gallery
- Public contact information
- Published local profile
How This Business Compares
How American Heritage Homes compares with the other 3 home builders on ProsGrade in Columbus, using public Google ratings and review counts.
- Rated 4.3 on Google, at or above the 4.2 average of other Columbus home builders on ProsGrade.
Services Covered
3 services- Custom home buildingOn customer land; adjustable floor plans or customer-provided plans.
- Designer Collection floor plansWellston: 2,024 sq. ft.; 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths.
- Simplified Collection floor plansCherry Creek – Simplified: 1,645 sq. ft.; 3 bedrooms, 2 baths.
Reviews
What customers say
Customers describe an attentive, communicative team that helps make the building process manageable. One homeowner says Curtis stayed available for questions after move-in; another says the team came within a week to put right drafty windows and split granite caulking.
Customer Reviews
Jeannie Biller
Corinne Strawser
Jamie Blade
Dustin Sullivan
Write a Review
Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does American Heritage Homes handle customer-provided plans?
Before construction, it reviews the plans alongside the homesite, goals and budget. If it sees opportunities to improve functionality, efficiency or buildability, it discusses them with the customer.
Can American Heritage Homes customers choose their own lender?
Yes. Customers may choose any mortgage lender they prefer.
When is the American Heritage Homes model home open?
The model home is open Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and closed on Sundays.








