Skip to content
FeaturedHome Builders in Columbus, Ohio

American Heritage Homes

Top Spot in Columbus Today 4.30 (46 reviews)(740) 983-4500

American Heritage Homes

American Heritage Homes builds custom homes on customers’ land throughout Central Ohio, including the Columbus metropolitan area. It began in 1995 with Bill Crum and Gary Libertini, who still lead the company.

Business Highlights
  • It reports receiving an Avid CX Gold Award for customer experience in custom homebuilding.
  • It says it has been a BIA of Central Ohio member since 1995.

Service Area

Central Ohio: all or portions of Delaware, Union, Madison, Licking, Fairfield, Pickaway, Ross, Perry, Hocking, Morrow, Muskingum, Clark, Champaign and Fayette counties.

Featured Local Business

American Heritage Homes is one of 4 home builders ProsGrade lists in Columbus, Ohio.

Featured
Featured on ProsGrade
Listing details

3 services listed: Custom home building, Designer Collection floor plans and Simplified Collection floor plans. Open Monday to Saturday. Rated 4.3 from 46 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How American Heritage Homes compares with the other 3 home builders on ProsGrade in Columbus, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Rated 4.3 on Google, at or above the 4.2 average of other Columbus home builders on ProsGrade.

Services Covered

3 services
  • Custom home buildingOn customer land; adjustable floor plans or customer-provided plans.
  • Designer Collection floor plansWellston: 2,024 sq. ft.; 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths.
  • Simplified Collection floor plansCherry Creek – Simplified: 1,645 sq. ft.; 3 bedrooms, 2 baths.

Reviews

What customers say

Customers describe an attentive, communicative team that helps make the building process manageable. One homeowner says Curtis stayed available for questions after move-in; another says the team came within a week to put right drafty windows and split granite caulking.

Customer Reviews

Michael Willis

Where do I begin? We started a little over a year ago working with Emily. We had been to many other builders in the area but it just seemed like she was listening to what we wanted and cared that it was right. Once we pulled the trigger to get started we were really introduced to the whole team. We had multiple interactions with Bill and Gary, which was neat to see the men in charge really involved. Derek was the guy running the job in the field and we had a great time working with him. John and Marcos were our men we saw daily and we had a blast getting to know them ( John especially he was great). Amy and Maggie kept everything running smoothly from the office and were extremely helpful and attentive during every conversation. I’m sure there are more to name, but let me just say the entire team was a pleasure to work with and will continue to recommend them to everyone that asks. Thanks for making our dream home a reality!! Mike & Rebecca
View full reviewShow less

Jeannie Biller

I know it's very simple, but I really like the illuminated Christmas Tree by your 23 South location. The star at the top is neat and I just look forward to seeing it. Wanted to say nice job way to go the extra step to brighten up my drive.
View full reviewShow less

Corinne Strawser

We would highly recommend AHH. We have officially been in our new home for a month and could not be any happier. Our home turned out exactly as we envisioned- lots of thanks to Tracee and Maggie for their design help! Our address made permitting somewhat confusing, but Brandi helped make the process as smooth as possible. Amy helped us with our budget and kept us updated on our account throughout. Our builder, Curtis, was absolutely phenomenal. He answered all of our questions quickly and honestly and ensured we had continuous progress on our home. Curtis is well-respected among all of the trades we spoke with and we felt we could trust him fully. As we have been settling in, Curtis has still made himself available to answer a few questions and we could not be more grateful. All of the tradespeople that worked on our house were efficient, clean, and did wonderful work. The folks at AHH are organized and communicative, making what could have been a stressful process easy and exciting. We finished on budget, on time, and with a beautiful, quality home we are proud to show our friends and family!
View full reviewShow less

Jamie Blade

Excellent builder with quality customer service and beautiful homes! Although building a home is always stressful, and even more so when you do it from a distance as we did, the American Heritage Homes staff went above and beyond to make our home building experience memorable and as easy on us as possible (not to mention exciting)! They built us an amazing, beautiful, high quality home with everything we asked for and then some! We have been in our dream home for nearly a year now, and they have continued to provide quality customer service. When a few of our windows got drafty and granite caulking split due to the natural settling of the house, AHH was out with their contractors within a week to make everything perfect again! They have also been extremely helpful answering our questions via phone or email from the beginning (Brandi and Curtis especially). They also have a very honest and down-to-earth approach to everything, which helped to put us at ease and keep us well-informed every step of the way. We absolutely love our American Heritage Home and all of their staff!
View full reviewShow less

Dustin Sullivan

After shopping several home builders, I found the people at American Heritage to be very straight forward with pricing and features. I spoke with a couple of their references and they loved their new home. They were easy to work with and we got incredible value for our money. They were even willing to explain some finer points of home construction that interested me particularly. Highly recommended!.
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does American Heritage Homes handle customer-provided plans?

Before construction, it reviews the plans alongside the homesite, goals and budget. If it sees opportunities to improve functionality, efficiency or buildability, it discusses them with the customer.

Can American Heritage Homes customers choose their own lender?

Yes. Customers may choose any mortgage lender they prefer.

When is the American Heritage Homes model home open?

The model home is open Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and closed on Sundays.