Cutler Cay Homes offers real estate services centered on the Cutler Cay community in Cutler Bay, FL, assisting buyers and sellers with local listings, pricing guidance, and contract coordination.
Local familiarity with Cutler Cay’s inventory and market patterns. Transparent communication on pricing, days-on-market, and comparable sales. Support through each step of the transaction and coordination with lenders, inspectors, and title professionals.
Cutler Cay in Cutler Bay, FL, with nearby surrounding neighborhoods as needed.
This featured listing includes fuller business details and a stronger local presentation for homeowners comparing nearby options.
This listing includes service information, customer review signals, a photo gallery, and public contact details to help homeowners compare this business more easily.
Featured listings may appear with fuller business details and stronger local presentation.
Buyer representation, seller representation, home valuation guidance, property showings, listing preparation advice, offer and negotiation support, and coordination through closing.
Reviews mention strong, hands-on support and attentive communication from specific agents during buying and selling, including frequent updates and proactive marketing. Some reviewers report concerns related to community security and association responsiveness, which are separate from brokerage services but relevant to neighborhood context. Positive notes center on responsiveness and diligence during transactions, while negative comments focus on the living experience and HOA/security issues within the community.
The worst mistake you could ever make in your life is moving here. From the time I came into this community till now my unfriendly neighbors have only harassed me and even broken into my backyard when I’m away. When you try to offer complaints you will be met with silence. Reporting a security guard that threatened me in front of my home or multiple neighbors or just finding a human to talk to behind their emails is impossible. I have lived here over 5 hellish years and never been directly communicated with to address any concerns no matter how hard I tried.
DO NOT MOVE HERE! I’ve been living here for sometime and the amount of car thefts and break-ins are unreal. Every car in my home has been broken into. My front neighbor’s vehicle was stolen. And so many other home owners have experienced the same issues. This has been going on for over a year. Security for the community does nothing here. They are either sleeping at the gate or on phone on personal calls. The association is horrible.
Trish Fuerst, is tireless in helping clients find the perfect home. She is gifted at making us feel as if we were the only thing in her day that needs undivided attention. My friendly advice , if you want the buying or selling of your home to be a good experience look no further than Trish Fuerst. Thank you for this opportunity .
Cutler Cay is an "upscale" community surrounded by a not so nice area, Cutler Ridge. It is also one of the neighborhoods in miami that has depreciated the most, the larger estate homes that originally sold for $800,000 to a million are now selling for $400,000 and sometimes even less. The houses there are also suffering from mildew problems and shoddy construction. It was built on a mangrove swamp and apparently the soil wasn't properly prepared. Many homes had the drywall replaced because they had Chinese drywall. The community is also very deserted, not many trees have been planted. In my opinion there are better areas. I'd rather buy an older and smaller home in Palmetto Bay, Kendall, or the Falls area.the surrounding schools are as bad
I had mistakenly signed with another realtor prior to signing Trisha. What a tremendous difference! Trisha found innovative ways to create foot traffic to our property in numbers far surpassing my expectations. She was visibly working my property every day and kept me informed every step of the way and had my home under contract within a week. I could not be happier with Trisha, if you need a realtor in Cutler Cay, do yourself a favor and sign Trisha on your behalf, you'll be happy that you did.
Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.
Compare local businesses, homeowner reviews, and featured providers across Cutler Bay.
Claim this listing to manage your business details, respond to reviews, and keep your public information accurate.