Skip to content
Featured

Tim O'Brien Homes

Home Builders in Madison, Wisconsin

Ranked #7 in Madison | Grade B

Tim O'Brien Homes

Home builder with a structured planning and construction process, office located at 2601 Crossroads Dr Suite 140, Madison, Wisconsin 53718.

Why Homeowners Choose This Business

Local knowledge of Madison, Wisconsin-area communities, a structured build process, and clear communication during selections and scheduling. Homebuyers note organized planning and responsive staff.


Service Area

Madison and nearby Wisconsin communities; contact for current build locations and lots.

Featured Local Business

This listing includes local business details for homeowners comparing nearby options.

Featured
Featured on ProsGrade
Listing details

This profile brings together available service information, customer review signals, photos, and public business details.

Featured listings may appear with fuller business details and stronger local presentation.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

A quick local comparison based on review strength, business detail, and local service fit.

  • Performs at or above the local average rating.
  • Has more review volume than many local competitors.
  • Shows strong customer satisfaction signals based on review quality and volume.

Services Covered

Renovation Services New Home Construction Customizable Floor Plans Design Center Selections Single-Family Homes Pre-Construction Planning Spec and Move-In Ready Homes Site Evaluation Homebuilder Madison WI Construction Management Energy-Efficient Home Options Post-close support Neighborhood Development

Services include new home construction, design consultations, floor plan selection, options and finishes guidance, and build coordination from permitting through closing.

Reviews

Customer Reviews

Shaun Davis

The home building process was great. I've been in the home for about 9 years now and sadly many of the corners that were cut during the build process didn't show up until later on... * Flooring was installed incorrectly, now we have huge…
View full reviewShow less
The home building process was great. I've been in the home for about 9 years now and sadly many of the corners that were cut during the build process didn't show up until later on... * Flooring was installed incorrectly, now we have huge gaps that slide whenever you walk on them. * The gutter system design was not correct, which is leading to water flushing underneath our front-sidewalks. Overtime, this has lead to our front-yard to sink, which is also causing major issues with our driveway. * Had to have our siding fixed multiple times due to poor installation. I don't think the siding was actually completed until about 6 months post move-in. * The truss alignment was off, which lead to weird gaps in the ceiling and everything just looks off. * The basement door leading to the basement has a tight enough corner where you can't even bring a couch down there, which really complicates the idea of furnishing our basement. Given how much I paid for the house, I was a bit disappointed.

Eric Hoffmann

My family worked with Renee at Tim O'Brien Homes on two occasions. In both cases we went another direction but our experience with her was superb. She was so kind and understanding and was looking to support our dream home. The process and…
View full reviewShow less
My family worked with Renee at Tim O'Brien Homes on two occasions. In both cases we went another direction but our experience with her was superb. She was so kind and understanding and was looking to support our dream home. The process and pricing was very clear and we are confident they build a quality home.

Margaret Breisch

Our interactions and home planning with Renee Bailey were nothing short of fantastic. She was knowledgeable, transparent and never pushy. Renee thoughtfully listened to our dreams and helped us design and customize our future home. We are s…
View full reviewShow less
Our interactions and home planning with Renee Bailey were nothing short of fantastic. She was knowledgeable, transparent and never pushy. Renee thoughtfully listened to our dreams and helped us design and customize our future home. We are so grateful for this positive experience and cannot recommend Renee enough for your future build partner!

Alisha Updike

We had a fantastic experience building with Tim O’Brien Homes! From start to finish, the process was smooth, organized, and far less intimidating than we expected. The team guided us through each step with clarity and care, making the entir…
View full reviewShow less
We had a fantastic experience building with Tim O’Brien Homes! From start to finish, the process was smooth, organized, and far less intimidating than we expected. The team guided us through each step with clarity and care, making the entire journey enjoyable. The craftsmanship is top-notch, and any issues that came up were handled quickly and professionally. Even after moving in, the warranty process has been thorough, and we truly appreciate the continued communication and support. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a builder who really stands behind their work!

Joseph Sapp

We just moved into our new Tim O’Brien Home just a week ago and are in love with it. We worked with Renee, Mallory and Samantha through the build process and always felt like we were in great hands. The home is well built and exactly what w…
View full reviewShow less
We just moved into our new Tim O’Brien Home just a week ago and are in love with it. We worked with Renee, Mallory and Samantha through the build process and always felt like we were in great hands. The home is well built and exactly what we dreamed of.

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

Special Offers

Free Estimate

This business may offer free estimates for some services.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of homes does Tim O’Brien Homes build in the Madison area?

They focus on new single-family homes with a variety of floor plans and options. Buyers can customize layouts and finishes during the planning and design phases.

How does the homebuilding process work?

The process generally includes consultation, plan selection, design selections, construction, and closing. The team provides timelines and check-ins to keep buyers informed at each step.

Can I customize the floor plan and finishes?

Yes, homeowners typically choose from available plans and personalize features like kitchens, baths, and exterior elements. Specific customization options depend on the community and build stage.

What support is available after move-in?

Buyers report that issues during and shortly after move-in are addressed through a defined follow-up process. For details on post-close support, contact the Madison, Wisconsin office or visit the company website.

Where can I see current communities and available homes?

Current neighborhoods and ready homes are listed on the company’s website. The Madison, Wisconsin office can also share up-to-date availability and viewing options.