Skip to content
FeaturedTaking CallsVerifiedHome Builders in St. Peters, Missouri

Cottleville Trails by McKelvey Homes

Featured in St. Peters Today 4.70 (19 reviews)(636) 429-4786

McKelvey Homes builds new homes at Cottleville Trails in Cottleville, Missouri. The company was founded in 1898, and the community features five lakes and a future pool and pool house.

Service Area

Cottleville, Missouri.

Featured on ProsGrade. Cottleville Trails by McKelvey Homes is one of 5 home builders ProsGrade lists in St. Peters, Missouri.

Listing details

2 services listed: New home construction and Quick move-in homes. Open 7 days a week. Rated 4.7 from 19 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Cottleville Trails by McKelvey Homes compares with the other 4 home builders on ProsGrade in St. Peters, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Ranks in the top quarter of the 5 St. Peters home builders on ProsGrade by Google rating and review volume.
  • Rated 4.7 on Google, well above the 4.1 average of other St. Peters home builders on ProsGrade.
  • Has more Google reviews (19) than 3 of the 4 other St. Peters home builders on ProsGrade.
  • The only one of the 5 St. Peters home builders on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

2 services
  • New home constructionLiberty Series layouts, including plans with three-car garages.
  • Quick move-in homes

Reviews

What customers say

Customers praise attentive staff and say the process felt straightforward. One homeowner particularly appreciated Terry's weekly construction updates.

Customer Reviews

Johnny Mac

Home buying is naturally stressful, but the experience is made so much easier when you’re working with true professionals. Drew at McKelvey Homes in Cottleville Trails, along with our Realtor, made the entire process smooth and successful. From the moment we walked into the model home, Drew greeted us with a warm smile and took the time to truly listen—understanding our needs, wants, and dreams. He helped match us with a home that not only met our expectations but exceeded them. Throughout the process, Drew was the definition of a professional—reliable, communicative, and always following through on what he said he would do. His integrity and dedication gave us an invaluable sense of relief during a typically overwhelming time. Even after closing and moving in, Drew’s thoughtful follow-up reassured us that we weren’t just another sale. We genuinely felt welcomed as new members of the McKelvey Homes family. His concern and care didn’t end with the transaction—it continued with every interaction. We also want to acknowledge Terry and his team during our final walk-through. Their attention to detail and commitment to quality were evident—they noticed things we had missed. That kind of character and integrity speaks volumes about the company culture. I highly recommend Drew and McKelvey Homes to anyone in the market. You’ll be treated with respect, care, and professionalism every step of the way.
View full reviewShow less

Spencer Page

We built our second home with McKelvey in Cottleville Trails, and it was an great experience! The super, Terry, sales associate & designer Suzie were phenomenal—professional, attentive, and made the process simple and stress-free. We absolutely love our new home! Highly recommend McKelvey!
View full reviewShow less

Dena Brown

My husband and I built a McKelvey Home in the Cottleville Trails subdivision. We are so happy with our decision! Suzie’s knowledge, experience and friendly personality made the sales process very easy. She kept us informed, guided us through the steps of choosing our new home and even celebrated with us after closing. From the pouring of the foundation to meeting us at the house after closing, Terry faithfully sent us communication each week with updates on the building of our new home. Any questions we had, Terry was a text away. By the end Suzie and Terry felt like family! We love what Cottleville Trails offers, the extensive trail system around the lakes, the small feeling town of Cottleville, the location with easy access to 364, Hwy k, Mid Rivers Mall Drive. Happy home owners!
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What room options does McKelvey Homes offer in the Jefferson plan?

Its flex room can serve as a home office or be converted into an optional fourth bedroom. The third bedroom can instead be made into a formal dining room.