Skip to content
FeaturedVerifiedLocksmiths in Greeley, Colorado

Keyway Lock and Safe

Featured in Greeley Today 4.90 (90 reviews)(970) 223-0334

Keyway Lock and Safe is a Greeley locksmith serving Larimer and Weld Counties and the surrounding area. It has been a locksmith since 1976 and handles residential, commercial and automotive work, lockouts, key cutting, and safe sales and service.

Business Highlights
  • Keyway offers upfront, accurate pricing and scheduling for lockout entry.
  • Keyway's key-cutting machines are calibrated as accurately as possible.

Service Area

Larimer and Weld Counties and the surrounding area.

Featured on ProsGrade. Keyway Lock and Safe is one of 5 locksmiths ProsGrade lists in Greeley, Colorado.

Listing details

6 services listed, including Lockout entry, Automotive locksmithing and Residential locksmithing. Open weekdays, closed on weekends. Rated 4.9 from 90 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Keyway Lock and Safe compares with the other 4 locksmiths on ProsGrade in Greeley, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Rated 4.9 on Google, at or above the 4.9 average of other Greeley locksmiths on ProsGrade.
  • One of 4 Greeley locksmiths on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

6 services
  • Lockout entryEntry to homes, offices and vehicles.
  • Automotive locksmithingIn-shop duplication of transponder and proximity keys; mobile key-making and vehicle reprogramming when all keys are lost.
  • Residential locksmithingExisting-lock rekeying; deadbolts; video monitoring; smart access and automation; hardware sales; mailbox locks and keys.
  • Commercial locksmithingElectronic access control; high-security and master-key systems; general maintenance.
  • Key cuttingHome and office; motorcycle and boat; farm and industrial equipment; keys by code; automotive transponder and proximity keys and programming.
  • Safe sales and serviceUL-listed safes tested against fire and burglary; American Security and Hollon Safe.

Reviews

What customers say

Positive comments describe a door assessment with detailed options and no attempted upsell, as well as a key-fob replacement billed at the quoted price. One customer said a vehicle-key programming visit ended with the ignition unable to turn and that the technician offered no solution. Another said the company changed a rekey appointment despite a stated need for a specific date.

Customer Reviews

Rob Benson

If you’re considering having keys programmed here, read this first. We brought in a fully functional vehicle to have new keys programmed. The technician failed to complete the programming but still charged us $80. To make things worse... When we tried to leave, the ignition would no longer turn. Prior to this visit, there were zero ignition or starting issues. The key would not rotate and the steering wheel was locked. The car arrived drivable. It left on a tow truck. The technician did not understand what had happened and offered no solution. After he failed, there was no clear explanation, no recovery plan, and no meaningful assistance. We were left standing there with a disabled vehicle. Because the wheels would not turn, the tow truck had to drag the vehicle out of the parking space. The company offered no assistance for the tow, we arranged rides, and lost two full days while the car sat at a mechanic. We were out several hours and several hundred dollars due to this failed visit. The owner, Jeremiah, changed his responses multiple times and ultimately did nothing to assist, or take responsibility for the inconvenience. No towing coverage. Nothing. If you value your time, your vehicle, and basic accountability, take this into consideration before scheduling service here. Extremely disappointing experience. ***after reading the reply... this is also a character issue, false and misleading, beware***
View full reviewShow less

Sara Shriver

Absolutely terrible customer service. I scheduled Keyway Lock and Safe eight days in advance and then received a call from the owner several days later saying that they'd received a big commercial job and needed to change my appointment. I explained that my rekeying needed to occur on a specific date due to an eviction but the company didn't honor my appointment even though I booked prior to the commercial gig. This company doesn't respect all clients and certainly doesn't honor appointments. Please give your business to someone else.
View full reviewShow less

Kathy T

Nolan at the Keyway Lock& Safe in Fort Collins store was professional, the only locksmith who gave me a breakdown on pricing to replace a key fob on a 2022 Chevy vehicle. The part came in faster than expected and I was able to make an appointment that day to have the service completed. I would 100% recommend Keyway Lock& Safe. The price quoted is what was charged and included the replacement key fob.
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Keyway prepare a quote that includes taxes?

It can prepare an official quote detailing all costs, including taxes.

What happens if Keyway cannot reach a lockout within a reasonable time?

Travel times vary, and if Keyway cannot arrive within a reasonable time, it offers names of other locksmiths to check availability.