Pro Business

McElheney Locksmiths

Toledo Locksmiths
Ranked #1 in Toledo | Grade A
4.60 (254 reviews)

McElheney Locksmiths

Neighborhood locksmith shop offering key duplication, lock hardware, and safes from a central Toledo location. Walk-in counter service is a common way customers get quick help with keys.

Why Homeowners Choose This Business

Convenient downtown location, steady weekday hours, and a showroom with safes and lock products. Reviews frequently cite fast key making and courteous counter help.

Service Area

Walk-in service at 1214 Jefferson Ave serves Toledo and surrounding areas. Call to confirm any mobile coverage.


How This Business Compares

A quick local comparison based on ranking, review strength, and market visibility.
  • Holds a strong position among local competitors.
  • Performs at or above the local average for Google rating.
  • Has more Google review volume than many local competitors.

Services Covered

  Locksmith Services
  Key Cutting
  Key Duplication
  Lock Rekeying
  Maintenance
  Door Hardware
  Repairs
  Safe Sales
  Safe Showroom
  Lock Repair
  High-Security Keys
  Commercial Locks
  Residential Locks
  Key Copies
  Locksmith Shop

Services include in-store key cutting and duplication, assistance with door locks and hardware, and sales of new and used safes. Availability of on-site service or emergency calls is not confirmed; contact the shop for current offerings.


Recent Reviews

4.60

(Based on 254 reviews)

Reviews highlight fast key cutting and helpful counter staff, with several noting quick service for hard-to-match keys. Many mention straightforward visits and easy parking. A smaller number of reviews report inconsistent customer service tone. Overall ratings trend positive with a strong volume of feedback.

Google Review
Shawn Parra on McElheney Locksmiths

Absolutely love this place they make keys for my store they were so friendly and Speedy I will go here every time I need keys made. Keep up the good work

Google Review
Lucas Fernandes on McElheney Locksmiths

Very good service and very prompt and courteous staff. Location has ample parking and is easy to access.

Google Review
Rhett Westfall on McElheney Locksmiths

Very rude and unprofessional staff. Spoke with 3 different people, all mad at the world. Just because you have been in business for generations doesn’t exempt you from being nice to customers. Wish you could give zero stars.

Google Review
Fredrick Shores on McElheney Locksmiths

My mother-in-law had an older front door I went to home depot, lowes, menards, other locksmith stores. No one could make this key. I walked in had the key 2 keys made in five minutes

Google Review
Matthew Horvat on McElheney Locksmiths

The best place in the area for knowledgeable service and great products. They can help you with all your lock and safe needs. (They also have cool historic locks, keys and safes)

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.


Frequently Asked Questions

The shop is typically open Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM. Saturday and Sunday are listed as closed. Hours can change on holidays, so it’s wise to call ahead. Current hours are also shown on their Google listing.

Yes, customers frequently report quick, while-you-wait key cutting. Timing depends on how busy the counter is and the type of key blank needed. For uncommon keys, availability may vary. Bringing the original key and any details helps speed things up.

Yes, the showroom includes a selection of safes, including new and used options. Inventory can change, so calling ahead for sizes and features is recommended. Staff can help compare models for home or business use. Delivery or installation details should be confirmed directly.

Several reviews mention successful duplication of older or hard-to-find keys. Results depend on the condition of the original and blank availability. If possible, bring the lock or detailed photos to assist matching. Complex keys may require extra time.

Mobile or emergency availability is not clearly stated in public sources. Call the shop to ask about current field service options and response times. If after-hours assistance is needed, confirm coverage before you go. In-store services are during regular weekday hours.
 Verified Listing

Opening Hours


  • Monday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tuesday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wednesday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thursday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Friday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Saturday Closed
  • Sunday Closed

Request Service


Business Details


Business Rating
4.60 (254 reviews) Pro Business
Address
1214 Jefferson Ave, Toledo, OH 43604
Phone
Business Type
locksmith
City Page

Location Map

Own This Business?


Claim this profile, improve your listing, and upgrade to Pro or Featured visibility.

Claim This Business