Skip to content
Business ProfilePainters in Carmel, Indiana

Preferred Home Improvements

Taking Calls in Carmel Today 5.00 (81 reviews)(317) 764-4220

Preferred Home Improvements

Preferred Home Improvements provides interior and exterior painting for residential and commercial properties in Carmel. It has been in business for 30 years.

Last Updated October 2, 2026.

Business Highlights
  • The company is American-owned.
  • It reports 6,000+ completed jobs.

Service Area

Carmel, Westfield, Fishers, Noblesville and Zionsville.

Local Business Taking Calls

Preferred Home Improvements is one of 11 painters ProsGrade lists in Carmel, Indiana.

Taking Calls
Taking calls through ProsGrade
Listing details

5 services listed, including Painting, Bathroom remodels and Basement finishing. Open weekdays, closed on weekends. Rated 5.0 from 81 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Preferred Home Improvements compares with the other 10 painters on ProsGrade in Carmel, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Ranks in the top half of the 11 Carmel painters on ProsGrade by Google rating and review volume.
  • Rated 5.0 on Google, at or above the 5.0 average of other Carmel painters on ProsGrade.
  • One of 10 Carmel painters on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

5 services
  • PaintingInterior and exterior; residential and commercial properties
  • Bathroom remodels
  • Basement finishing
  • LVP flooring
  • Sheet-rock repairs

Reviews

What customers say

Customers praise Don's communication and professional manner. One customer noted crisp transition lines and care with protecting trim and carpet; another described a three-day cabinet-painting job with cleanup at the end of each day.

Customer Reviews

Kreg Stewart

Bathroom remodel. Don did a great job. Hit the time frame as needed. Very communicative, friendly, professional and honest. We had a 1.5 bath with a floor issue. Don converted it to a 2 bathroom. Workmanship is awesome and beautiful. He split one bathroom, replaced tub with walk in shower; took space into 1/2 bay and put in a tub. I had people say that what he did couldn’t be done.
View full reviewShow less

Dwebb J

I have been looking for a painting contractor who would also be able to do some minor siding repair before painting. I found Preferred Home Improvements, LLC, by noticing consistent high marks of satisfaction by previous customers. It says a lot about a company who doesn't require any deposit or down payment until the job is done and the customer is completely satisfied. The owner communicated constantly during my home painting project to make sure things were going well and to see if I had any questions or concerns. He has a great painting crew; they do careful work. The siding repair looks perfect. I will be using them again when it comes time to interior painting. Highly recommend.
View full reviewShow less

Aaron Martin

We recently hired Don and Preferred Home Improvements to repaint several areas of our home and power wash and stain our deck before getting it ready to sell. He came highly recommended from our contact at the local Sherwin Williams paint store. Don was professional, provided a quote that we thought was fair and reasonable for a lot of work, and his crew did an outstanding job very efficiently. I appreciated the quality of the painting and staining, attention to detail with crisp transition lines at the trim and ceiling and the care with taping and protecting our trim and carpet. We prefer to hire locally owned businesses for home services and we have found a great one.
View full reviewShow less

Nina Huntsinger

We recently had Don Johnson's crew paint our kitchen and laundry room cabinets It was a three day process, taping, sanding, priming, and, painting. At the end of each day the crew cleaned up and removed plastic covering so we could use our appliances. The crew was very respectful of our home giving us as much privacy as they could while working in the kitchen and laundry. We are very happy with the cost and the finished product.
View full reviewShow less

Nghia Le

Don has an amazing, hard working crew. I can’t stress enough how important it is to have people you can trust to help out. When Don first came out to bid for the job, I could tell he’s done this for a while. He is very knowledgeable and thorough. We walked through every room, made sure it was the colors that we wanted. Don answered all my questions and was very professional, patient, and courteous. When the job was done, he did a follow up to make sure we were satisfied with the work. Don will communicate with you both via text or by a phone call. He is easy to get a hold of should you have any questions or concerns.
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Preferred Home Improvements require a deposit before work is complete?

One customer reported that no deposit or down payment was required before the job was done and the customer was completely satisfied.