Skip to content
Business ProfilePainters in Carmel, Indiana

Priority Painting & Finishes

Listed in Carmel 4.80 (92 reviews)

Priority Painting & Finishes

Priority Painting & Finishes is a painting contractor in Carmel, founded in 2004. Manny Navarrete took over in 2017, and the company handles residential and commercial projects.

Last Updated October 2, 2026.

Featured Painters in Your Area

Compare a few featured businesses in this area.

Business Highlights
  • The company is family-owned and operated.
  • The company offers lifetime touchups.
  • The company carries liability and workers’ compensation coverage.
  • The company offers a one-year labor warranty on lime-based products.
  • Masonry painting has a 25-year product warranty.

Service Area

Carmel and Zionsville.

Active Business Listing

Priority Painting & Finishes is one of 11 painters ProsGrade lists in Carmel, Indiana.

Active
Public local listing
Listing details

10 services listed, including Interior painting, Exterior painting and Wallpaper installation and removal. Open Monday to Saturday. Rated 4.8 from 92 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Priority Painting & Finishes compares with the other 10 painters on ProsGrade in Carmel, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Has more Google reviews (92) than 6 of the 10 other Carmel painters on ProsGrade.
  • One of 10 Carmel painters on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

10 services
  • Interior paintingSherwin-Williams Emerald and Cashmere; Benjamin Moore Aura and Regal for walls
  • Exterior paintingSiding, trim and doors
  • Wallpaper installation and removalInstallation and removal
  • Cabinet paintingRenner Wood Coatings, Benjamin Moore Cabinet Coat and Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane
  • Limewashing, whitewashing and lime paintingRomabio products; one coat for limewash and whitewash, two coats for lime painting
  • Masonry paintingExterior brick, stone, concrete and stucco
  • Roman clayMineral-based plaster with a smooth, matte finish
  • Decorative plaster finishesVenetian plaster, Romabio Marmorino and mineral painting
  • Staining
  • Epoxy work

Reviews

What customers say

Customers describe communication as responsive, praise the crews’ professionalism and note fair pricing. One customer said Manny resolved a wall color-match issue and noted that furniture was covered and cleanup was thorough after ceiling-crack and nail-pop repairs. A customer also praised a husband-and-wife team’s installation of bold, patterned wallpaper in two rooms.

Customer Reviews

Patrick Zimmerman

I found Priority Painting through my membership with NeighborServe when my usual painter wasn’t available and I needed to find someone quickly. Manny was very responsive from the start — he got back to me right away and was able to provide a quote within just a few days. The project itself was straightforward: repairing settling cracks in the ceiling and fixing nail pops that had developed over time. The team lead who was on-site was excellent — very professional, detail-oriented, and on top of everything throughout the job. They took great care to cover all the furniture and did a thorough cleanup when the work was completed. There was a small issue with a color match on one wall, but Manny handled it professionally and ultimately made sure the situation was resolved. The pricing was fair, and the overall experience was very positive. I would absolutely use Manny and his team again in the future.
View full reviewShow less

John Kramer

Team came to my rescue after previously scheduled painter cancelled on us. Extremely happy with Priority Painting. Manny and Francisco were great to work with pricing was fair and quality of work was exceptional. I am very picky and couldn’t be more pleased. Have asked for quotes on 2 additional projects I would like their service. Highly recommend!
View full reviewShow less

Samantha Morton

I stumbled upon Priority Painting Services when searching for someone to hang our wallpaper, and I’m so glad I did! We had two rooms, both with bold and patterned paper, and I was a bit nervous about it being done well. Manny was always very communicative, and the husband and wife team who hung our wallpaper were excellent. They were both kind and patient with our young kids who are curious and want to be involved, and their work was exactly as I hoped. I would highly recommend!
View full reviewShow less

Kelli Bastin

I am a realtor and had a luxury listing where we needed excellent service, communication ans a quick turn around. Manny and his team were professional, punctual and communicated extensively with both myself and my sellers. They even fixed a couple handy-man type items for us so we didn't have to call multiple contractors. Thank you Priority Painting for making this project a success for my sellers! 10/10 recommend!
View full reviewShow less

Carole Wills

Priority Painting is our favorite painting company. We've used them many times for several major projects, both interior and exterior. They are professional and exacting in both the painting and clean up. Pleasant and considerate when I'm working at home. They offer experience and consultations about color and problem areas, and even repaired and painted our basketball goal. This time they gave a face-lift to two bathrooms, a bedroom and my office. I love their suggestions for updating these rooms. I highly recommend Priority Painting.
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do interior repaints and exterior painting projects usually take?

Timelines vary; interior repaints average 2–3 days and exterior projects average 3–4 days.

What preparation does Priority Painting & Finishes include?

Proposals include the necessary prep work, so customers do not need to prepare the surfaces being painted.

Does Priority Painting & Finishes provide the paint?

The company supplies the paint for its projects.

Does someone need to be home while Priority Painting & Finishes works?

Customers do not need to be home during the work, but the company asks someone to be present on the first day of interior or exterior projects.

Does Priority Painting & Finishes offer financing?

Financing options let customers spread out a project’s cost rather than pay one large amount.