Skip to content
FeaturedTaking CallsPlumbers in Indianapolis, Indiana

Carter's My Plumber

Top Spot in Indianapolis Today 4.90 (1,185 reviews)(317) 893-2462

Carter's My Plumber

Plumbing service for Indianapolis homes with a strong track record in water heater repair and replacement, leak fixes, and drain and toilet service. Reviewers note timely arrivals, clear communication, and tidy work.

Why Homeowners Choose This Business

Clear communication, punctual arrival, and careful cleanup are consistent themes in recent feedback. The team explains repair options, keeps budgets in mind, and follows up on scheduled maintenance. Booking is straightforward and confirmation texts help customers know who is arriving.


Service Area

Indianapolis and surrounding metro neighborhoods. Call to confirm coverage and appointment times for your location.

Featured Local Business

Carter's My Plumber is one of 11 plumbers ProsGrade lists in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Featured
Featured on ProsGrade
Listing details

17 services listed, including Water Heater Repair, Water Heater Services and Fixture Installation. Open 24 hours, 7 days a week. Rated 4.9 from 1,185 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Carter's My Plumber compares with the other 10 plumbers on ProsGrade in Indianapolis, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Ranks in the top 10% of Indianapolis plumbers on ProsGrade by Google rating and review volume.
  • Rated 4.9 on Google, at or above the 4.8 average of other Indianapolis plumbers on ProsGrade.
  • Has more Google reviews (1,185) than 7 of the 10 other Indianapolis plumbers on ProsGrade.
  • One of 11 Indianapolis plumbers on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

17 services

Common requests include water heater repair and replacement, flushing and maintenance, leak and hose line fixes, toilet repair and replacement, drain clearing, and basic fixture installs. They also handle sudden failures such as ruptured tanks or flooded areas and can provide straightforward estimates before work begins.

  • Plumbing Services
  • Supplier
  • Water Heater Repair
  • Water Heater Services
  • Fixture Installation
  • Water Heater Replacement
  • Tank Flushing
  • Leak Repair
  • Installations
  • Toilet Repair
  • Repairs
  • Toilet Replacement
  • Drain Cleaning
  • Hose Bib Repair
  • Plumbing Inspection
  • Burst Pipe Response
  • Sump Pump Check

Reviews

Customer Reviews

A M

We had a fantastic experience with Mr. Plumber, especially Luke W., who was thorough, professional, and incredibly helpful throughout our water heater installation. He took the time to clearly explain the issues and our options, making sure we felt informed and confident in the decisions being made. Luke not only did an excellent job solving the problem, but he also kept our budget in mind and helped us choose a cost-effective solution. We truly appreciate his care, expertise, and quality work, and highly recommend Mr. Plumber.
View full reviewShow less

Dan Tudor

I've had a great experience with Carter's My Plumber from the start. They were quick to respond when I needed a new water heater a couple of years ago and provided great service at a reasonable price. I've been very impressed with their commitment to honoring the included annual service. They have reached out each year to schedule the service. Other companies I've dealt with in the past have not always been so eager to live up to their obligation. All the employees that I've dealt with have been very professional and courteous.
View full reviewShow less

Joey Zelasko

We had our water heater rupture yesterday, and Carter’s My Plumber came to the rescue in a big way. From the very first interaction, their team was professional, responsive, and incredibly easy to work with—exactly what you hope for during a stressful situation. Zach Douglas and Wesley Bash were absolutely fantastic. They arrived on time, worked efficiently, and kept everything clean throughout the entire process. The installation of our new tankless water heater was done flawlessly, and they took the time to clearly explain how everything works, what to expect, and how to maintain it going forward. No rushing, no confusion—just great communication and top-notch workmanship. It’s rare to find a company that’s this dependable, knowledgeable, and respectful of your home. Carter’s My Plumber exceeded our expectations in every way, and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone needing plumbing work. Truly a five-star experience!
View full reviewShow less

Nicki Dorman

Carter's My Plumber has never disappointed. They truly go above and beyond in their approach to earning your business and delivering solid service. I've used them for multiple plumbing needs from an urgent call for a hose leak that flooded my basement to installation of my new water heater (which they now flush yearly). I like that they text reminders and send a picture of the tech who will be arriving.
View full reviewShow less

Angela Clark

I had a great experience with Carter's My Plumber. Miles, the technician, was very informative and knowledgeable. He tried everything he could to unclog my toilet before having to remove it. He got the clog out, replaced the toilet, and cleaned up the mess. Explained everything he had to do. I called Carter's in the evening and they came out the next day. Very pleased with their services and will call on them again should the need arise. Highly recommended.
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.