Skip to content
FeaturedTaking CallsRenovation Contractors in Indianapolis, Indiana

The Heartland Builders

Top Spot in Indianapolis Today 5.00 (129 reviews)(317) 420-2455

The Heartland Builders

The Heartland Builders is an Indianapolis remodeling contractor founded in 2019. It handles kitchens, bathrooms, basements and whole-home renovations, as well as exterior remodeling. Its wider construction work includes roofing and siding, with GAF roofing systems and James Hardie siding named in its history.

Business Highlights
  • The company describes itself as minority-owned and locally rooted.
  • The company lists general contractor license GL1900204 and says it is fully licensed and insured.
  • It offers an in-house one-year workmanship warranty and a GAF Systems Plus Warranty.
  • It says interest-free financing is available through Synchrony.

Service Area

Indianapolis and surrounding communities including Carmel, Fishers, Greenwood, McCordsville, Noblesville, Westfield and Zionsville.

Featured Local Business

The Heartland Builders is one of 8 renovation contractors ProsGrade lists in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Featured
Featured on ProsGrade
Listing details

6 services listed, including Kitchen and bathroom remodeling, Basement and whole-home remodeling and Exterior remodeling. Open weekdays, closed on weekends. Rated 5.0 from 129 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How The Heartland Builders compares with the other 7 renovation contractors on ProsGrade in Indianapolis, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Ranks in the top quarter of the 8 Indianapolis renovation contractors on ProsGrade by Google rating and review volume.
  • Rated 5.0 on Google, at or above the 4.9 average of other Indianapolis renovation contractors on ProsGrade.
  • Has more Google reviews (129) than 6 of the 7 other Indianapolis renovation contractors on ProsGrade.
  • One of 8 Indianapolis renovation contractors on ProsGrade rated 4.7 or higher from at least 10 reviews.

Services Covered

6 services
  • Kitchen and bathroom remodelingIncludes shower remodels
  • Basement and whole-home remodelingBasement finishing and broader interior updates
  • Exterior remodelingDecks, windows, gutters, siding and exterior painting
  • RoofingAsphalt shingles, TPO and EPDM systems
  • Multifamily and commercial workRemodeling, roofing, siding and gutters
  • Other interior workLaundry room remodels and drywall installation and finishing

Reviews

What customers say

Several customers praise professional crews and clear communication, and Abby Marshaus says the team quickly corrected misunderstandings. One customer, however, reported misaligned tiles, crumbling grout and plumbing they said was not code-compliant, and said final payment was demanded before several requested fixes. That reviewer also said some other issues were promptly addressed after payment.

Customer Reviews

Abby Marshaus

We hired Heartland Builders to transform our original 1949 bathroom into something much more modern - boy, did they deliver! Leen, Hilary, Carlos and crew were highly professional from start to finish, with timely, thorough communication and helpful consultation. The team went above and beyond to deliver the bathroom we envisioned (working long hours to meet schedule), and were quick to make corrections on the few occasions that there were misunderstandings. You can tell that the team takes great pride in the work they do, and that having a high standard for quality is a priority for them. We plan to bring Heartland Builders back for future projects around our home, and highly recommend you do the same!
View full reviewShow less

Ramya Rao

We hired heartland builders for finishing our 1100 sq feet unfinished basement space. Logan from Heartland worked with us throughout out this process. They were very quick to start the process and finished it in 6 weeks end to end. They even gave us a very competitive pricing , with a high grade finish. The workers who came to finish the job were very professional though out the process. They gave us choices to choose from. If we were too busy, Logan would do a run down and even send pics for the choice we would like. They were very flexible with choices also if we needed anything additional. It was all so easy. I really recommend these builders. From making the drawings to delivering it awesome job throughout. They are a great team.
View full reviewShow less

Matthew Vinyard

We had our master bathroom completely renovated, kitchen countertops replaced and backsplash added, and most of the first floor painted by Heartland. Positive: Customer service was responsive to issues that came up during construction. Workers were polite. Project was scheduled quickly after signing contract and work was completed on time. From a distance, some of the work looks good. Cons: Upon close inspection, overall quality for most work was mediocre. Many kitchen and bath tiles are misaligned and the bathroom grout was already crumbling. After catching several shortcuts, including non-code compliant plumbing, we are concerned what else was missed that will cause future issues. When we requested fixes for several items, they demanded final payment before they would address them. After seeing how they handled the first few issues and seeing egregious craftmanship. For example, caulking instead of grouting certain spots, using a stair tread for a window ledge, ripping our insulation batts open to use the fiberglass to cap open drains, hanging a chandelier incorrectly, etc. We decided against asking for much else to be fixed for fear they'll just make it worst. They did offer to ask the tile installer to determine how easy it would be to fix the uneven tiles, but we chose not to accept because we did not have faith in Heartland's ability to do it right or cleanly. However, some other issues were indeed promptly addressed after payment. When we got the final invoice, the owner claimed they threw in our shower benchtop for free. However, we requested the bill from the stone company because we noticed the unit price of our stone was way off, he happened to 'realize' the benchtop price had been included in the bill all along i.e. we were paying for it anyway and offered us a credit for it instead. We still haven't received a copy of that stone bill. In my opinion they are either dishonest about pricing or they don't care enough to do proper accounting. They also chose not to return the many boxes of unused tile even though they said they would. In summary, I feel portions of the experience with Heartland were a waste of an investment. Look at the attached pics and make the decision for yourself, it is what Heartland found as acceptable.
View full reviewShow less

Julie Dalbey

I used Heartland Builders for two jobs in my house - one was general construction/remodel work and the other was to build a new deck. The guys did a fabulous job! I found the pricing competitive. Communication with Logan was great and he answered all of my questions timely and professionally. Special shout out to Enoch who is a wonderful perfectionist! He worked on both jobs and made sure that everything was as it should be! I will definitely be using the team again this fall!
View full reviewShow less

Darren Pirtle Jr.

I reached out to The Heartland Builders as I was looking to get the exterior of my house repainted. I could not be any happier with the service that was provided. They brought our vision to life and were a pleasure to work with. They were very transparent with us and made sure that we were happy each step of the way. The quality of the work speaks for itself. We will definitely be working with them again in the future!
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

When was The Heartland Builders founded?

It was founded in 2019.

Does it offer a workmanship warranty?

The company says it offers an in-house one-year workmanship warranty, along with a GAF Systems Plus Warranty.

Does it offer financing?

It says interest-free financing is available through Synchrony.

Will a project require a permit?

The company says that depends on the project's scope.