Skip to content
Business ProfilePlumbers in Indianapolis, Indiana

Carter's My Plumber

Listed in Indianapolis 450 reviews(317) 893-2485

Carter's My Plumber

Carter’s My Plumber is a family-owned plumbing company serving Indianapolis and Central Indiana, with three generations of the Carter family working together. It handles plumbing repairs, drain cleaning, water-heater work and sewer services.

Featured Plumbers in Your Area

Compare a few featured businesses in this area.

Business Highlights
  • It lists plumbing license CO88900054.
  • The company says its plumbers are licensed, bonded and insured.
  • It says it provides clear pricing before work begins.
  • It offers free in-home estimates for specific plumbing jobs.
  • It advertises a warranty with tankless-water-heater work.

Service Area

Indianapolis, Greenwood, Whiteland, Franklin, Bargersville, Trafalgar, Mooresville, Wanamaker, Beech Grove, Southport, Plainfield, Perry Township, Homecroft, Avon, Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, Meridian-Kessler and Zionsville.

Active Business Listing

Carter's My Plumber is one of 11 plumbers ProsGrade lists in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Active
Public local listing
Listing details

12 services listed, including Plumbing repairs, Drain cleaning and Hydro jetting. Open 24 hours, 7 days a week. 450 reviews.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

How Carter's My Plumber compares with the other 10 plumbers on ProsGrade in Indianapolis, using public Google ratings and review counts.

  • Ranks in the top half of the 11 Indianapolis plumbers on ProsGrade by Google rating and review volume.

Trust Signals

Open 24 hours for scheduling and urgent plumbing needs.

Services Covered

12 services
  • Plumbing repairsleaking pipes, faucets, running toilets, broken fixtures and low water pressure
  • Drain cleaningkitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms, floor drains and main drain lines
  • Hydro jettinghigh-pressure water; video inspection to check pipe condition
  • Water heater repair and replacementtraditional tank water heaters
  • Tankless water heater servicesgas and electric systems; repairs, maintenance and installation
  • Sewer line servicesinspection, repair and replacement
  • Trenchless sewer repair
  • Water line repairrepiping water lines
  • Slab leak locating and repair
  • Water softener installationsalt-based ion exchange, salt-free conditioning and dual-tank systems
  • Well pump servicewell repairs, flow tests and water testing
  • Sump, backup and sewage pumps

Reviews

What customers say

Customers praise the technicians’ kind manner and clear explanations. Examples include John and an apprentice resolving one customer’s low shower pressure by adjusting a recently installed valve cartridge, and a customer noting that a new water heater was installed within a few hours.

Customer Reviews

Natalie Roberts

I knew I needed to replace the water heater after it had been leaking and the hot water ran out. I went online Sunday and was able to get an appointment for Tuesday afternoon. Mark was the first to come out and look at my old unit. Hey did a thorough assessment and gave me options. I had a 13 gallon tank, but 14 gallon tanks are cheaper so Mark made sure the measurements would work. Mark walked me through all of my options and was able to get a technician out the same day. My technician was John P. John called when he was 30 min from my home making sure I was still available. John was nice and explained what he was going to do and the best options for moving tanks in and out of the house. A few hours later, the new water heater was in! John ran through what he did, showing me pictures and explaining where things were. John then answered my questions and took payment before leaving. Had a great experience with Crater’s My Plumber and I’m grateful that over the next years they will be serving my water heater!
View full reviewShow less

Susie Halstead

I needed a new toilet because subfloor had ruined flange. John did an amazing job and even hooked up my new vanity. Old houses are a challenge but he got it done, super great guy!

Kelly “Shirley England” Harrison

I have to take this minute to tell you my experience with these two gentlemen and Carter's Plumbing. John and Carter installed my new water heater today. These two guys that showed up I honestly couldn't have asked for anything more perfect than what they did, how they performed and the highest level of excellence and kindness given from both of them. Absolutely the best and I couldn't have gotten any better anywhere else. Carter's Plumbing is beyond the most top notch family business I believe I've ever came across in my time and I worked personally for a few family owned businesses when I was young . I am not a rich person and needed help and Carter's Plumbing, Danny, John and Carter treated me more humble and kind than I ever could have imagined. Trust me when I say this amazing work that got done today thanks to John and Carter I will be taking care of my mom with hot water again. From my family to John and and of Carter's Plumbing we so humbly thank all of you for your kindness and hard work you did for my family.
View full reviewShow less

Brooke Statler

Water stopped working at 10 PM last night and Carters Plumbing was able to send John out to our house the next day to fix it! Our pipes had frozen due to the cold temps. Lucky for us, John was able to troubleshoot the situation, use a heat gun on our pipes, and get our water up and running all in 30 minutes! Super kind and thoughtful technician, also gave us tips on how to prevent them from freezing again. Thank you so much John!
View full reviewShow less

dave mason

I had a problem with very low water pressure in my shower. I swapped out the shower head and another company replaced the cartridge in the shower valve, both to no avail. The other company advised that my entire shower valve needed to be replaced, a very expensive repair......not to mention the cost of damage done to wall and tile in the process. Before committing to that, I called Carter's My Plumber to get a 2nd opinion. They promptly dispatched John and his apprentice Carter to my house. They were extremely professional, knowledgeable, and friendly as they meticulously examined and analyzed the situation and patiently explained what they found and answered all of my questions. Bottom line: they had to make adjustments to my new valve cartridge that the other company had installed and that fixed the problem with my shower......at less than 1/10th of the cost of replacing the valve. Wow! Thank you very much, Carter's My Plumber, and specifically your employees, John and Carter! I'm so glad I chose you guys!
View full reviewShow less

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.

We'll email you a link to confirm your review. It's only sent in once you click it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Carter’s My Plumber inspect sewer pipes before hydro jetting?

A technician performs a video inspection to check that the pipe is in good condition. If it has collapsed, hydro jetting is not an option; the sewer line must be dug up and replaced.

What does Carter’s My Plumber’s tankless water-heater maintenance include?

A maintenance flush descales the heat exchanger, cleans the inlet water filter, inspects burners and ignition components, and checks venting, gas and electrical connections.

How long can a water-heater replacement take?

A standard replacement can often be completed within the same service visit. Plumbing, gas, venting, electrical or setup-area modifications may take longer.

Can Carter’s My Plumber repair a leaking water heater?

A leak at a valve or plumbing connection may be repairable. Water leaking through a corroded or damaged tank usually means the unit must be replaced.

How does Carter’s My Plumber select a water softener?

It evaluates water hardness and household use to determine the system size and type. After installation, it tests the system and explains operation, maintenance and salt management.