Pro Listing

Natale Builders

Home Builders in Buffalo, New York
Ranked #6 in Buffalo | Grade B
4.10 (34 reviews)

Natale Builders

Natale Builders is a Clarence-based home builder creating custom, neighborhood, and patio homes throughout Western New York. The team supports clients from homesite selection and plan customization through design decisions and construction oversight.

Why Homeowners Choose This Business

Homebuyers can explore model homes, adapt plans to fit needs, and work with a team that coordinates selections, schedules, and communication throughout the build. The Clarence-based staff provides local market knowledge and access to established neighborhoods in the Buffalo, New York area.

Service Area

Buffalo, New York metro and WNY, commonly including Clarence, East Amherst, Amherst, Williamsville, and nearby towns.

Local Pro Business

This listing includes additional business details, homeowner trust signals, and stronger comparison information.

Pro
Additional business details
Listing details

This listing includes service information, customer review signals, a photo gallery, and public contact details to help homeowners compare this business more easily.

This profile includes more business details, homeowner trust signals, and a fuller public presentation.

  • Verified listing details
  • Service information
  • Customer review signals
  • Photo gallery
  • Public contact information
  • Published local profile

How This Business Compares

A quick local comparison based on review strength, business detail, and local service fit.
  • Shows review activity that is competitive for this local market.

Services Covered

  Renovation Services
  Custom Home Builder
  Installations
  Design-Build Homes
  Neighborhood homes
  Patio Homes
  New Construction Homes
  Home Plan Customization
  Model homes Buffalo
  Project Management For Builds
  Selections Coordination
  Western New York Home Builder
  Clarence NY home builder
  Energy-Efficient Home Options

Services include custom home design-build, neighborhood and patio homes, plan customization, design studio selections, and coordinated project management from preconstruction through final walkthrough.


Reviews

Recent Reviews

4.10

(Based on 34 reviews)

Reviews mention organized design and selections support, with several homeowners praising team communication and the ability to tailor floor plans. Positive feedback cites timely project delivery in some cases. Critical reviews note concerns about pricing transparency, detail in proposals, and punch-list workmanship items like fixtures and finishes. Overall sentiment reflects strong guidance during design with mixed experiences on pricing clarity and final details.

Google Review
Fred Duncan on Natale Builders

My experience with Natale Builders was disappointing from the start. They refused to provide any firm pricing until I put down a $10,000 “refundable” deposit, which in hindsight should have been a major red flag.

Once the deposit was paid, I asked multiple times for a quote. It took nearly two weeks to receive, and what I got was a generic two-page summary with minimal detail and vague estimates.

After deciding not to move forward, I asked for my deposit back on Thursday, October 30th. Instead of promptly returning it, they first tried to sell me another property and said the deposit “wasn’t ready.” Communication was evasive and inconsistent from that point on.

A full week later, they finally issued a refund on November 6th, but only after deducting $1,750 in “fees.” According to their letter, this included charges like $95 for a meeting, $95 for correspondence (Texts), and hundreds more for “estimating” and “drafting,” even though I was only ever provided one of their standard layouts with small changes. There was no true itemized evidence of custom drafting or real estimating work to justify those costs.

What was presented as a refundable deposit turned into a slow, frustrating process with arbitrary deductions and poor communication. It took over a week after my refund request just to get a partial check back.

If transparency, professionalism, and trust matter to you, I strongly recommend avoiding this builder.

Google Review
Kerry Boser on Natale Builders

Just finished building our home with Natale Builders and couldn’t be happier with the finished result! Lisa was terrific early in the process helping us to select the perfect location and layout. Jess and the rest of the team were very well organized and made the design and selection process very straightforward and as painless as possible. Would highly recommend Natale builders!

Google Review
Bruce Kinyon on Natale Builders

Natale Custom Homes built us a "Forever Home"!
The very friendly sales staff were very accommodating adjusting model home blueprints to our personal specifications. The Design Selections Coordinator kept us on task directing us to vendors to make our personalized selections of all aspects of our home. The Project Manager kept our custom home on schedule and informed us throughout the building process. Finally, after we moved in, the Service Manager promptly addressed any follow up items we brought to his attention. We truly enjoy our Natale "Forever Home"!

Google Review
Jose Santiago on Natale Builders

This post is a little late considering the builder finished my house five months ago however, I did want to give an update. All I can say is well done! You guys did a great job! My house was finished in a record 8 months. To me this is fantastic considering all of the obstacles. Building through a pandemic, a labor, shortage, and back ordered materials, Frank, Dean and tyler also everyone at the Natale Builders in the background deserve a special thank you from me and my family. There will always be delays when building a new house tensions will run high but that is just the nature of the beast. However, this special group of people really know how to keep it together and keep the train moving forward. They certainly are a well oiled machine .Thank you very much Natale builders.

Google Review
Peter Crowley on Natale Builders

As a first time home buyer, I was excited to have a brand new house built from the ground up. Unfortunately, I discovered eventually that the attention to detail in building my forever home was lacking in many aspects like the following … leaking shower drain into basement, no access panel installed to reach motor for jetted bathtub, loose wiring on a couple of light switches, improperly measured door frames, electrical outlets incorrectly placed on mirror rather than along side it, and a significant amount of cracked ceiling plaster due to poorly measured room transitions. When I had aluminum fascia fall off the exterior of my home (which should not have fallen off if properly nailed)…I reached out for assistance and was ignored. Although I probably had “rose-colored glasses” on during this building process…a home builder with years of experience should have a better attention to detail (rather than hope for first-time home buyer ignorance).

Reply to Owner Response - I reached out to Natalie Builders one month ago about assistance in finding a contractor for replacing the aluminum fascia that fell off my exterior (I was having difficulties finding a handyman for the job & the item was not a piece that could be purchased at a Home Depot because it had a specific edge bent into it in order for it to match the rest of my home). I received no response from Natalie Builders to my inquiry for assistance - but I was fortunate to find a repair person that indicated the fascia should not have fallen off as it did if secured properly initially. As for my home being 14 years old (thank you for the quick reply to my review and taking the time to investigate how old my house is) - I have maintained my house properly (I never thought much of the leaky shower drain issue until I saw it within another home owner's review). The poorly measured door frame & awkward ceiling transition that is cracking (see photos) as well as the lack of any access panel to the motor of the jetted bathtub are not a reflection of the age of my home. Ultimately...I know this is a "buyer beware" situation but it should be stated for first-time home buyers that builders (who build 100s of homes) should be even more aware of these details.

Write a Review

Share your experience with this business. Reviews are moderated before they appear publicly.


Frequently Asked Questions

They build custom homes as well as neighborhood and patio homes in communities around Western New York. Buyers can start from a model plan and customize layouts, finishes, and features.

Clients meet with the team to review plans and then make coordinated selections through recommended vendors. A design coordinator typically helps keep choices organized and aligned with the build schedule.

Yes, plans are often adjusted to fit layout preferences and lifestyle needs. Common changes include kitchen configurations, primary suite layouts, and finish packages.

They serve the Buffalo region and Western New York, including Clarence, Amherst, East Amherst, Williamsville, and surrounding communities. Availability can depend on active neighborhoods and lot options.

Reviews reflect mixed experiences, with some homeowners satisfied and others seeking more detailed breakdowns. It’s best to request a clear scope, specifications, and allowances before signing.
 Verified Listing

Opening Hours


  • Monday 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM
  • Tuesday 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM
  • Wednesday 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM
  • Thursday 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM
  • Friday 7:30 AM – 12:00 PM
  • Saturday Open 24 hours
  • Sunday Open 24 hours

Request Service


Business Details


Business Rating
4.10 (34 reviews) Pro Listing
Address
9159 Main St Suite 3, Clarence, NY 14031
Business Type
general_contractor

Compare local home builders in Buffalo

Browse local businesses, homeowner reviews, and featured providers across Buffalo.

View Buffalo Home Builders

Location Map

Own This Business?


Claim this listing to manage your business details, respond to reviews, and keep your public information accurate.

Claim This Business